Assessing Neal Morse’s Cosmic Cathedral

Hello faithful Spirit of Cecilia readers. As always, thank you for joining us for our latest review. Up this time, Neal Morse’s new supergroup, Cosmic Cathedral and the band’s debut album, Deep Water. In addition to Morse himself on keyboards, the band includes Phil Keaggy on guitar, Chester Thompson on drums, and Byron House on bass. While this is a Morse-driven project, the band co-wrote much (but not all) of the music, and Morse shares credit, lyrically, with Keaggy on one song. The CD comes out from Insideout Music/Sony. Here at Spirit of Cecilia, Tad and Carl have especially praised the album. In this review, Tad and Brad (wow, our names rhyme) assess the new album.

Brad: Well, I’m not sure I’m the proper person to start this conversation, especially given how much Tad and Carl like it. I must admit, I’m still rather skeptical of the album. Parts of it, I love. In particular, I’m quite taken with the keyboards, the guitar work, bass (though, the bass needs to be higher in the mix), and drums. Each of these musicians is, simply, spectacular.

I’ve seen other reviewers refer to the album and the band as espousing “Yacht Prog,” and, for better or worse, I can see that complaint, especially with the first half of the album. I wouldn’t call it “Yacht Prog,” but I might be tempted to refer to it as “Adult Contemporary Prog,” a kind of gentle prog for the older set.

And, since I’m being negative, I’ll be negative about this as well. The lyrics are a little too evangelical for my tastes. As I hope is obvious–after all, we are dedicated to the Spirit of St. Cecilia, patron saint of music–I have no problem with one expressing his or her faith in his or her art! My gosh, most of the best art in the history of the world has been inspired by faith. But, when Morse sings “I sing for Jesus–it was for me He died/He unlocked the door to heaven/Now we can pass from death to life,” my soul cringes just a bit. It’s not that I disagree with the theology or the sentiment, but I disagree with the lack of art in the statement. Given the weight and gravity of the subject matter, these lyrics should have been deep, stirring, and beautiful–not yelled out in a vulgar fashion.

Again, though, there’s much I like about the album. Though I didn’t like the first few moments of keyboard on the first track, “The Heart of Life,” once the guitar kicks in, the song simply rocks. And, I really liked about a ⅓ of the Deep Water Suite. Again, I was especially taken with the guitar work throughout the album and very much so on the suite. It struck me as very much a Christian version of a Spock’s Beard epic.

I should also admit that I have really mixed feelings about Morse. At times in my adult life, I’ve been quite taken with him–especially with the last Spock’s Beard album, Snow, as well as with several of his solo albums, Testimony, Lifeline, and Question Mark especially. I also really like his work with Transatlantic. I’ve seen him in concert several times, and I’ve been an off and on member of his Inner Circle fan club. But, his blatant anti-Catholicism–especially on Sola Scriptura–really turns me off. I don’t see that in Cosmic Cathedral, however.

Tad: Thanks for getting this conversation going, Brad! As you mentioned, I like this album a lot. I wasn’t prepared to enjoy it as much as I do, though. I pretty much buy anything Morse releases, but his previous album with The Resonance, No HIll For a Climber, didn’t really resonate (!) with me. I listened to it several times, but nothing was very memorable.

With Cosmic Cathedral, on the other hand, I think Morse has surrounded himself with an extraordinary group of musicians. Phil Keaggy is one of the greatest living guitarists, and Chester Thompson is a phenomenal drummer – I’ve been a fan of his since the days when he toured with Genesis. I was surprised that Morse tapped Byron House to play bass, since his background is primarily in country music (Foster and Lloyd, Emmylou Harris, Vince Gill, Buddy and Julie Miller, et al.), but he’s a great choice. I’ve admired his work for years, as he brought a jazz sensibility to every project he’s worked on. These three men really push Morse, I believe.

That said, I can see why you might label this album “Yacht Prog”. I could do without “I Won’t Make It”, and “Walking In Daylight” has a definite seventies laid-back vibe to it (but Keaggy’s guitar solo redeems it in the end). But I love the first track, “The Heart of Life”. It has such an energetic intro, and it never lets up. Thompson’s drumming is fantastically driving throughout. I have a ton of Keaggy albums, and I’ve never heard him let loose like he does on this track. Melody-wise, it’s immediately recognizable as a Morse composition – lots of buildup to a satisfying resolution. Lyrically, I think this song is fairly restrained – I agree that sometimes Morse can hit you with a two-by-four when a pat on the shoulder would suffice, but I have to admire his consistency – it’s been 22 (!) years since he recorded Testimony, and he has remained true to his convictions.

Brad: Tad, thanks so much for this. I really appreciate your viewpoint. After reading this, I went back to Morse’s Sola Scriptura. Here’s a sample of his lyrics.

Giving up the time we’ve got to live a life completely

Giving over to the lust that rages in the mind

The Captain fills his place with gold while all the ship is sinking

Calls himself the Bishop-Prince and blood’s his favorite wine

Gardens grow as people know and sense the smell of slaughter

Every soul and Saxon senses something’s gone awry

The woman in the wilderness – the beast has nearly got her

Men surround the Bishop-Prince and sing their bloody cry